Horror Stories – Better When Read Together?

By: Rachel Wlock

As they say, “two heads are better than one.”

As they say, “two heads are better than one.”

Many of us probably think that the scariest way to watch a horror movie is alone, in the dark. I would have to agree with this statement. There’s no one there to help you when you hear footsteps down the hall or when you see the shadows of monsters that are creeping around in the dark. However, written horror stories are different. Because they cannot rely on jump-scare techniques, they often prey on the psyche and require more depth of thought. As with any story, it is easier to think through meanings when you have other people to bounce ideas off of.

Take for example, the story “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been,” by Joyce Carol Oates. While reading it for class, I was somewhat put off. I didn’t enjoy it. Connie was one of the more boring and unlikeable main characters that I’ve ever read – though I would later realize this was a deliberate characterization. Even after reading it a few times, I still didn’t really understand what was going on in the narrative; it just seemed weird. I thought Arnold Friend and his odd companion Ellie might be aliens. Perhaps I should have done some background research into the story and into the creation of Arnold Friend’s character, but I didn’t. Instead, I went to class with my own interpretation, feeling slightly annoyed.

When I left class that day, I was surprised to find that my opinion of the story had done a complete 180° turn. I actually did like it now! Group discussion had opened my eyes to interpretations that I simply did not come up with on my own. Whereas before I had thought that Arnold Friend was just some weird omniscient figure who came to Connie’s house to attack her, I had suddenly been introduced to more possibilities. Perhaps he was actually just an exceptional stalker, based on a serial killer in real life. Or maybe he was the Devil, dressed up in a disguise to hide his horns and hooves. I prefer the Devil interpretation, though it may not have been what the author intended, simply because I’m partial to stories in which the Devil comes to Earth as a human. To me, talking about this story made it scarier because these other possibilities for the character seemed more terrifying than the idea of aliens that I had before. The fact that Arnold Friend was based on the real life Charles Schmid was particularly frightening because it was a reminder that sometimes horror isn’t just a figment of someone’s imagination; these are real threats to people’s lives. Discussing this with the class intensified the fear more, as often happens to emotions in a group setting.

Of course, this does not always happen. Sometimes bad stories are just bad. Regardless, there are many others like this one that only get better – and scarier – the deeper you think about them. Much research has been done on the impact of reading in groups, and although much of it is about children (and not horror stories), we can still apply the findings to our class. Group discussion facilitates making connections and understanding other points of view. This works particularly well for horror because as you think of more scary aspects of the stories and meanings behind them, it can only get more frightening.

This principle is valid for other media, as well as written stories. Consider this piece of horror art by Michael Whelan. A student of horror might analyze this work to understand what makes it scary. Maybe you imagine that the person responsible for the unfortunate situation of the victim is still on the loose and attacking others. Or possibly, you see this and you think that the subject of the painting is already dead, and has come back to life as a zombie. The thing about much of art (including writing and filmmaking as art forms) is that there are so many different ways to interpret one work. Because of this, discussion with others will almost certainly introduce a person to more ideas than they would have thought of on their own, giving them more things to fear.


4 thoughts on “Horror Stories – Better When Read Together?

  1. I definitely agree that you can get more out of horror in written form when you discuss it with others. Every time after going to class so far, I have liked stories more (or have been more scared by them) like you said about “Where are you Going, Where have you Been.” Discussing “Penpal” also brought this up for me. I was certainly disturbed by “Penpal” when I read it alone, but discussing it with others brought many things out that I had never thought of. For example, the many theories of who the antagonist could be and what his motives are– from schizophrenia to pedophilia. There is definitely something to be said about collaborating when reading horror and the new perspective it brings.

  2. I agree! I felt the exact same way when I read “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” – the class discussion was almost scarier than the actual story itself. Plus, I think that part of it is the fact that discussing the story makes you think more about it. I know that when I’m reading by myself, I’m sometimes inclined to just put the story down and not think about it too deeply, especially if it was a story that didn’t particularly grip me. When I know that we’re going to discuss the story, I have no choice but to ruminate on it more than I would’ve otherwise, and just sitting with the story tends to multiply the horror. And, like you said, the discussion always brings up ideas that I’d never considered!

  3. I absolutely agree. I thought Penpal was extremely creepy, not especially “scary” but definitely eerie especially for those who grew up in small towns (me) and had an innate trust in other people. However, talking about it in class made me more and more scared of the character that Penpal produced. Listening to other people’s interpretations of his motives made me think about the story in a different way which did scare me a lot! When I watch, read, or experience horror in another way, I don’t usually go further in depth; maybe I’m too scared what I will find but I think it’s because once I experience that phenomenon, I’m ready to move on. However, I am so glad we discuss in depth each assignment we have because I think it makes it more interesting to understand and, frankly, more scary.

  4. Discussing the stories in class make it so much easier to understand the actual horror. I hated “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” when I first read it. I thought it was kind of stupid and not scary, just weird. I didn’t even know what to think of Arnold Friend and Ellie, they just confused me, but after we discussed it in class it was 10x better. Same with “Severed,” when I read it I was bored at parts and then at some parts I got creeped out. When we discussed it in class it all made so much more sense. But as for watching/reading horror alone, I don’t like to do it by myself, and if I do it by myself I have to talk to someone about it!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s